Skip to content
Carbide snow plow blades, inserts and wear parts — engineered in Rayong, Thailand
Request a Quote

Scraping First, Salting Second: Sequencing on Lots and Walks

Should a crew scrape first and treat second, or treat first?

Request a quote See the blade range
Illustration for scrape first salt second: a salt pile, a plow truck and a globe
Published October 28, 2026 Updated November 8, 2026 4 min read Topic Setup Symptoms
4 answersAsked 28 October 2026·Ice & Deicing

SENTHAI Editorial Team

TALK / ICE AND DEICING DISCUSSION
Buyer question

On our parking lots and walks, should the crew scrape first and treat afterwards, or treat first? We want less product use but we do not want ice left behind.

Main answerSENTHAI Editorial Team

Main answer

Short answer
It depends on the conditions. In general, removing as much snow as possible before applying de-icer means less material is diluted, and treating first can help when snow is bonding to the surface. Choose by conditions and record results. This is practical advice and cites no product-rate data.

Two sequences compared

Factor Scrape first, then treat Treat first, then scrape
Best when Snow is loose and the surface is not yet bonded Ice or packed snow is bonding, or when forecasts call for icing
Material use De-icer works on a thin remaining layer, so less may be needed Material works on a thicker layer, and some may be pushed away with the snow
Edge contact Edge meets loose snow and any hidden ice Bond may be weaker, so the edge may scrape more easily
Timing Two passes, with a gap if you wait for material to act Needs time for treatment to work before the scrape
Risks Ice left under a thin layer if treatment is skipped Material wasted if it is pushed off before it acts

How to choose on site

The order matters: scrape first, salt what the blade cannot reach, and decide on site rather than from the forecast alone.

  1. Look at the snow: loose, wet, packed or icy.
  2. Look at the forecast: is it still snowing, or is a freeze coming?
  3. Choose the sequence in the table that fits.
  4. Record what you did, the conditions and how the surface looked after an hour.
  5. Adjust next time based on the record.

What it means for the edge

Scraping well before treating puts the edge to work on the bulk of the snow. Keep the edge in good condition so that it leaves a clean surface, since a poor scrape leaves more for the treatment to deal with. Track edge wear alongside product use on a few lots to see the full picture.

Limit

Product choice, application rate and local rules vary, so follow your supplier’s instructions and local guidance.

A simple test you can run

Pick two similar lots. On one, scrape first and treat second; on the other, treat first and scrape second, for the same storm. Record product used, time taken and surface condition after an hour. Swap the sequence on the next storm to reduce the effect of the lot itself.

Boundary: No application rates or savings are stated; follow your product supplier’s instructions and local rules on de-icer use.

Further reading on this site.

Pool Salt and Water Softener Salt for Ice: What Works, What Does Not ↗A blade scrapes well at first and leaves more snow later in the shift. What should the log capture? ↗Carbide snow plow blades ↗Truck-Mounted Pavement Temperature Sensors: What They Read and What Operators Do With It ↗Chatter Lines on Rink Ice After Resurfacing: Blade Checks to Run First ↗Freezing Rain Playbook: Edge, Timing and Hardware Notes for Glaze Events ↗

Field-check perspective

Reply

↳ Replying to SENTHAI Editorial Team

Look at the surface after the first pass and again after treatment. A simple photo at set times shows how the sequence worked. Note temperature and whether the snow was still falling. After a few storms, the notes tell you which order suits which condition on your own lots, not on someone else’s.

Maintenance perspective

Reply

↳ Replying to Field-check perspective

A worn or chipped edge leaves streaks that the treatment then has to deal with. Keep the edge in good order so the first pass counts. Rinse equipment after salt contact and inspect hardware, since treatment products can speed up corrosion. Record both product use and edge wear, so you see the combined cost.

Purchasing perspective

Reply

↳ Replying to Maintenance perspective

If scraping better reduces product use, the saving shows up in the product line, not the edge line. Track both together on a few sites for a season. Share the comparison with the person who buys materials, so that a decision on edges is made with the full cost in view and not only the edge price.

Next step

Question: should a crew scrape first and treat second, or treat first?

↑ Back to the questionRead the main answer

Related products

Detail of a rubber-flex segment on a JOMA style snow plow bladeJOMA Style Blade — Rubber-Flex Edge with Carbide Wear Segments Row of tungsten carbide inserts welded along the cutting edge of a snow plow bladeCarbide Snow Plow Blade for Highway and Municipal Fleets Samples of different tungsten carbide grades for snow plow applicationsTungsten Carbide Inserts for Snow Plow Edges

Related articles & discussions

Send us a blade drawing and get a quote back

Tell us the machine, the material you are clearing and the wear life you need. Our engineers reply with the edge profile, carbide grade and packing that fit the job — usually within one working day.

Request a quote Browse the blade range