Skip to content
Carbide snow plow blades, inserts and wear parts — engineered in Rayong, Thailand
Request a Quote

Grade 5 vs Grade 8 Bolts on Cutting Edges: Questions Before You Swap

Can you swap grade 5 for grade 8 bolts on a cutting edge, or the reverse?

Illustration for grade 5 vs grade 8 bolts: a torque wrench, a balance scale and a county grid map
4 answersAsked 1 November 2026·Materials & Standards

SENTHAI Editorial Team

TALK / MATERIALS AND STANDARDS DISCUSSION
Buyer question

Can we swap grade 5 for grade 8 bolts on our cutting edges, and what should we ask the maker before changing the bolt specification?

Short answer
Do not swap on the assumption that “higher is better”. The grade tells you about strength, but not about the right torque, the right bolt shape for the countersunk or carriage-bolt holes in the edge, or how the bolt behaves under impact. Ask the plow or edge maker which bolt they specify and why. I cite no standard figures here, since I did not read the standard.

What a grade does and does not tell you

Property Does the grade tell you?
Strength class of the bolt material Yes, in general; the head marking shows the class
Correct bolt head and shank shape for your edge holes No; check the edge and moldboard specification
Correct tightening torque for your joint No; depends on size, thread, lubricant and the maker’s spec
Behaviour under repeated impact Not directly; ask the maker
Corrosion resistance No; depends on plating or coating

Questions to ask the maker or supplier

The bolt questions are decided by the joint, not by the bolt catalogue.

  1. Which bolt, size, head style and grade do you specify? Ask for the combination, not one attribute of it.
  2. What torque should I use, and for dry or lubricated threads? The number is meaningless without the friction condition.
  3. Is there a reason for the grade? Some joints rely on the bolt yielding; others need it to stay elastic.
  4. What nut and washer go with it? A matched nut keeps the failure in the bolt rather than in the thread.
  5. Is any plating or coating specified? Coating changes friction, and friction changes torque.

What to check on the bolts you have

You cannot manage what you cannot identify, and bolt grade is the first thing to disappear in a mixed bin.

  1. Look at the head markings and record them for a sample of your bolts. The markings are the only reliable identification once the box is gone.
  2. Check whether the markings are consistent across a box, and ask the supplier if they are not. Mixed grades in one box are a common supply problem.
  3. Keep different grades in separate, labelled bins. Mixing is how an 8.8 ends up where a 10.9 was specified.

Why mixing causes trouble

A stray bolt of the wrong type can sit in a joint unnoticed. If the joint then loosens or fails, you will not know whether the cause was the bolt, the torque or the edge. Marking and bin discipline remove that uncertainty.

Limits

This article gives no strength values or torque figures. Take them from the maker’s documents and the relevant standard.

Boundary: No strength, torque or standard value is cited because the bolt standard was not read; use the plow maker’s specification and the standard itself.

↳ Replying to SENTHAI Editorial Team

Buy bolts to the maker’s specification, written on the purchase order with size, head style, grade and finish. Ask the supplier for a certificate or marking evidence when the joint matters. Avoid buying mixed lots of unlabelled bolts. If a cheaper bolt is offered, ask for the specification in writing and compare it with the maker’s, line by line.

↳ Replying to Purchasing perspective

Follow the plow maker’s bolt and torque specification for every edge change, and keep a torque record. Do not reuse bolts that are stretched, corroded or damaged. Keep bins labelled by size and grade, and check head markings before installation. If you find a bolt you cannot identify, replace it rather than guess.

↳ Replying to Maintenance perspective

If you are thinking about changing bolt grade to cure loosening or breakage, first find out why the bolts fail. Common causes are torque, worn holes and a loose mount, none of which a stronger bolt will fix. Ask the maker for advice and trial any change on one truck, with a log, before you change a whole fleet.

Next step

Question: can you swap grade 5 for grade 8 bolts on a cutting edge, or the reverse?

Send us a blade drawing and get a quote back

Tell us the machine, the material you are clearing and the wear life you need. Our engineers reply with the edge profile, carbide grade and packing that fit the job — usually within one working day.